YC Deveshwar is a
man with a mission. The ITC chairman has not only expanded the
company portfolio from tobacco to fast moving consumer products, but
has also done it in a socially and environmentally sustainable
manner. At the recent CII-ITC Sustainability Summit held in New
Delhi, he talked to FE'sRajiv Tikoo about his concept of vision,
values and vitality.
The summit was
organised by the CII-ITC Centre of Excellence for Sustainable
Development. Excerpts from the interview:
How is the annual summit
shaping up?
I think there is
significant progress. We are just into our second event, but it's
getting better qualitatively as well as quantitatively.
More companies are
participating and competing for the summit awards.
You seem to be
very passionate about the summit. The fact that you are the
chairperson of the advisory council of the CII-ITC Centre can't be
the sole reason.
I take interest
because the idea of sustainability is very important for our society
as well as the world. You can see, for example, global warming has
made even the developed world talk about inclusive and sustainable
growth.
What does the
summit seek to achieve?
The idea is to tap
experiences of people and create networking opportunities for
building a repertoire of experiences and convert it into knowledge
tools so that you can make better advancement towards
sustainability.
How is ITC living
it up as an example?
I can say it with
considerable pride that ITC is the only company in the world of its
size and complexity or diversity that is water positive.
ITC is not only water
positive, but it also creates five times more freshwater resources
than it consumes. ITC sequesters twice the amount of carbon that is
emitted out of its operations. And it is nearly zero solid waste
disposal company. Besides, our e-choupal and our other social
initiatives create sustainable livelihood for millions of small and
marginal farmers. So, this is our contribution in terms of triple
bottomline. And, of course, ITC's financial success is well known.
Why has the
expansion of e-choupal initiative slowed down?
E-choupal can
function only in those areas where we buy commodities. So we have
gone wherever soya, wheat, coffee and cashew are grown. Now we are
getting into horticulture. It increases the scope of expansion of e-choupal
for us.
In the meantime we
are now completing our full strategy in areas, which have an e-choupal
network. We are enlarging the role of the hubs that service e-choupals
and are setting up choupal sagars. We need to get land, settle
ownership issues and obtain legal clearances and permission to
build, which is taking time. It's not that we have slowed it down,
but you know that it takes time in our country.
So, are you
preparing for big retail expansion like others?
It's much more than
retail. What is modern retail? It brings two things-choice and
convenience-to the consumer. We are bringing these benefits to small
and marginal farmers.
When he is selling
his produce, he has a choice of selling it either to us or to
erstwhile mandis.
When he is buying, we
are also giving him a choice. We are bringing to him multiple
suppliers of seeds, pesticides, fertilisers, etc. We are also giving
him information on weather and prices. So his choice is enlarged.
Isn't everyone
targeting the bottom of the pyramid market?
Though this is the
bottom of the pyramid (BOP) market, there is a big difference.
Targeting the BOP is assuming that there is a market and exploiting
it. Our model is to help the farmer increase his purchasing power
and empower him so that he becomes part of the market. Our model is
to enlarge the size of the cake and also aim for a larger share of
the cake.
So, is this
corporate social responsibility (CSR) for competitive advantage?
We are working with a
philosophy that we will deal with the entire value chain from the
seed to the stomach. The first step of our supply chain is to get
farmers to be competitive and to produce quality products at cheaper
rates for us to be competitive internationally.
We are not starting
from just buying raw material. We are starting from making our raw
material better in quality and cheaper in cost through enhancement
of the productivity of the small farmer. So sustainability is an
integral part of our business. It's in our enlightened
self-interest.
Are you taking CSR
beyond its conventional definition?
CSR is already there,
but now we are talking about how to mobilise consumers. A small part
from the sale of our products goes into a fund that we have set up.
We draw money from it to undertake water harvesting pro grammes,
social farm forestry, children's education and women's empowerment,
etc. So if you are buying ITC products, you are contributing to the
fund. If it catches the imagination of consumers, then our
competitors will also have to do it. We want to get the attention of
the consumer to create competition for CSR. The big idea is how to
create a bigger market for CSR.
Are your products
still cost competitive?
Our products have to
be cost competitive. It can't be otherwise. We can't ask people to
pay more. We say that all things being equal (our products may be
even superior), here is one more reason why you should buy our
products.
What is the
response of your shareholders and board of directors to your
approach?
You see, if you are
able to deliver results in the short run, then every body supports
you. There is a prob lem if you stop producing results in the short
run. That is why there is a need for level playing field. It's a
pity that there is no way to differentiate between companies that
are doing a good job for the society and those companies that are
not doing such a good job.
So, how can
markets reward responsible companies in India?
We need to bring
awareness among the civil society. Governments must also frame
enabling policies. Our balance sheets deal with corporate governance
norms to protect the shareholder, but businesses don't work for only
shareholders. They also impact the society.
So we are saying that
please make disclosures not only of financial status but also of
social capital and natural capital.
How would you like
it to be done?
Why can't we rate
businesses for their sustainability contributions? There should be
some guidelines like those of the Global Reporting Initiative. Or,
let us develop new standards here. We need to build institutional
frameworks. Let us have Trust Marks for each sector of the economy
and rate industries according to the contribution they make to the
society. Then those ratings should go on to their products. Let
people get an informed choice.
But how are you able
to internalise sustainability in the first place without an enabling
external environment? What is it that you have and others don't?
There are three
components that are very important for any company-vision, values
and vitality. Vitality is the new concept here. I have talked about
it earlier, though. It's the ability to translate your vision and
values into something productive. Vitality means the capacity to
juggle more than one ball-to deal with the short run, the medium run
and the long run. ITC is able to do this because we also work for
the short run. Today if you are doing well only in the long run and
your short run is bad, you get punished. You will not be there to
deal with the long run. That is why we say that we need to build an
enabling environment in our society that places value on the long
run.
So, will it make
you unsustainable in the long run if the policy and the competition
do not move in the same direction as yours and at your pace?
I hope not. It will
only make us work harder. My organisation has a system of
distributed leadership. So it will be our collective capacity to
deal with these three dimen sions-short, medium and long-that will
decide our sustainability.
You keep on
expanding your portfolio of products. Are you also planning to trim
it at some stage?
Well, if it's not an
appropriate part of our portfolio... You see, I am not personally
wedded to any of these products. I do not want to give up something
in the interest of the short run, if it is beneficial for ITC in the
long run. At the same time, if I can with a small operation make the
body fitter and deal with the balance of the short, the medium and
the long run, I might do it. I want to be allowed to do the long
run, even if it requires in the mean time to sacrifice some part of
the body to be able to carry on rather than extinguishing it.